Snap Back to Reality*

… sooner or later a false belief bumps up against solid reality, usually on a battlefield--George Orwell.

Crash! Boom! Bang!
In George Orwell's 1946 essay, In Front of Your Nose, he writes that most people have a "secret belief that one's political opinions, unlike the weekly budget, will not have to be tested against solid reality". I find this to be true for every set of beliefs people have, whether political, theological, ethical, etc. Flat Earthers live in the contradiction of belief in a flat earth while dismissing the real pictures of a blue and green marble hanging in space. Leaders who are not self-aware overestimate their own competence despite evidence to the contrary. We often vote for the politician who promises the best solutions to our everyday problems, even though we secretly may be aware that those solutions are untenable. People of faith may hold the belief that God must only give them the good things despite what their scriptures say about poverty, persecution, etc. In the end, however, as Orwell writes in the same essay, "… sooner or later, false belief bumps up against solid reality, usually on a battlefield."
Eminem's song, Lose Yourself, references this bump against reality when his protagonist--Rabbit--is snapped back to reality and he realizes he must either give up or fight forward. These bumps against "solid reality" can occur anytime--perhaps a child dies unexpectedly or a supervisor sits us down for a conversation about our performance and we realize our job is on the line or sickness overwhelms us and our capabilities change--really, anytime life comes crashing down around us and our beliefs no longer make sense in the new reality.
Theology vs, Reality
We must allow time for our theology to catch up to our reality.
In this moment, as life forces our beliefs out in front of us, the first questions are often theological in nature.
Why is God allowing this?
Where is God when I need Him?
Is God punishing me?
Does God even exist?
Why isn't He taking care of me?
Is God even listening to me?
And while we want INSTANT answers, we must allow time for our theology to catch up to our reality. "Why?" you ask? It's because of the law of unintended consequences:
The cure may be worse than the disease
Humanity has only recently begun attempting to understand mental illness. At one point, doctors tried trepanation, or drilling holes into the skull. More recently (1930s-1950s), doctors developed the idea of sticking an ice pick into the frontal lobes to sever nerve pathways, a procedure known as lobotomy. Turns out, treating mental illness through bodily mutilation is not that helpful!
The Perverse Effect
When the French ruled Vietnam, the city of Hanoi became infested with rats. The solution? The government offered a bounty for every rat tail handed in. Easy, right? Entrepreneurs decided they could make a quick buck by BREEDING rats and then cutting off and turning in the tails. With no use for the rats themselves, breeders then released the rats, actually INCREASING the rat infestation!
Verschlimmbessering (or disimprovement)
Cecilia Giménez attempted to restore a fresco of Christ wearing a crown of thorns that had been painted on the wall of her church. You can see the result of this disimprovement here--


The bottom line is this--forcing our theology to catch up to our reality too quickly generally creates a "final condition [that] is worse than the first" (Matthew 12:43-45) because we reach for the easy solutions. Suicide, self-mutilation, damaged relationships, depression, financial difficulties, loss of faith, etc., are real-life examples of what happens when we don't take the time and do the work of allowing our theology to catch up to our reality.
Playing Catch-up
So, life has come crashing down. Our view of God and the divine is in conflict with what the reality we see in front of us. Even in this traumatized time, we recognize a need to let theology catch up to reality. HOW do we do that? I like to utilize the Reflect-Reset-Relax cycle.
Once we catch our breath after the initial gut punch, we must take the time to Reflect.
Am I only responding to the emotions of the moment?
Have I given myself time to process what has actually happened?
Do I understand the actual impacts, to include the positives?
Do I have a full 360-degree understanding of the event?
Do I have tunnel vision or have I opened the aperture for a broader picture?
What community can I gather around me or engage in?
Is God big enough to handle this situation and is my faith strong enough to let Him?
Having reflected and taken stock of the reality we now find ourselves in, we come to a point where we can Reset.
What am I actually called to do in this situation?
What are the important things I should begin focusing on?
Whom am I able to lean on?
Where has God made Himself visible?
To paraphrase Hamlet, are there more things to my [theology] than I had previously dreamt of?
What promises am I relying on? Where is my hope placed?
Finally, as life begins to return to normal, we begin to rebuild our shattered world with a stronger foundation that we can then Relax into.
What did I learn about self, God, theology, etc.? How has my understanding grown?
In what ways might I prepare myself better for the next time life crashes in?
What new tools can I rely on for next time?
What best practices will I apply to my daily life?
The old saying is "To teach is to learn twice." Whom can I teach these new principles I've learned?
In the future, how will I avoid the trap of unintended consequences?
What foundational faith stance am I relaxing back into that grounds me?
Dear Future Me
When she was about six, my eldest daughter crashed her bike. It was the most traumatic event of her little life and the best response she could muster was to lie prostrate on the ground and wail loudly for a very long period of time. The problem was that she was IN THE MIDDLE OF THE STREET! I finally had to pick her up out of the road, and carry her home before she was run over. From that time on, we had many discussions about keeping it together in an accident until she was able to be in a safe place. Sure enough, about twelve years later, we get a phone call--
"Mom, Dad, I've had a car wreck."
"Okay, what happened and where are you now?"
"I'm safe. I pulled off to the side and called the police. They're here now …."
"Great! You're okay? No one is hurt? Now call your Aunt; she can be there in five minutes and you need a hug. We love you!"
Five minutes later, her Aunt arrived and our eldest was in a safe place to break down into tears. She had reflected on her situation, reset her expectations and emotions, and then was able to relax into a foundational family member.
Life is going to crash; our theology is going to need time to catch up to our new reality. This is unavoidable. The Reflect-Reset-Relax cycle will provide a firmer foundation and a more rapid snap back to reality.
Note
Much of this post comes from my own personal experiences in the last few weeks. A health emergency in my family has kept me out of the blogosphere and working our own reflect-reset-relax cycle. I'm hoping to be back on a regular schedule as we relax into our new normal.
*Eminem. "Lose Yourself." Lyrics, Genius, 2002, genius.com/Eminem-lose-yourself-lyrics.
*Orwell, G. (2010, December 9). In front of your nose | the Orwell Foundation. Www.Orwellfoundation.Com. https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwell/essays-and-other-works/in-front-of-your-nose/"… sooner or later a false belief bumps up against solid reality, usually on a battlefield.”--George Orwell



Comments